Tech start ups dominated by men run the risk of 'inherent insularity' warns new white-paper

Tech start ups dominated by men run the risk of ‘inherent insularity’ warns new white-paper

Despite significant awareness being raised and resources being thrown at closing the gap, tech continues to be an industry dominated by men. In 2019, Australian women hold just 28 percent of roles and far fewer when it comes to those in leadership.

So why does this continue to be the case? Are too few women interested in the industry or are there just significant biases still prohibiting them from getting ahead?

According to a new white paper conducted by KPMG and Think & Grow, startup leaders are calling for better hiring processes, saying a persistent boys club holds the industry back and blocks women from getting a fair bite of the cherry.

Based on in-depth qualitative and quantitative research with over 26 experienced startup board members and founders in the UK, Australia, US and New Zealand, the white paper explored best practice across the recruitment industry in those nations.

Worryingly, it found that 65 percent of startup boards don’t appoint members via a formal process and instead source members through personal and professional networks, with limited use of professional recruiters.

Perhaps unsurprisingly then, 72 percent of all male-run start-ups had failed to appoint any women to their boards, while in Australia that number was slightly reduced with 62 percent of start-up boards sans women.

Most board members mentioned that suitable board members were typically sourced via the start-up Founder’s network (professional 58% and personal 27%).

Change appears far from afoot with 76 percent of start-ups failing to have any diversity targets or metrics in place.

“Although women-led businesses are one of the fastest growing segments of entrepreneurship, only 38% of startup boards in Australia have female members. This barely hits the diversity quota set by the Australian Institute of Directors in 2016,” says Amanda Price, Head of High Growth Ventures at KPMG Australia.

Price adds that as a result of “boys club” culture, women are missing out on board positions because they lack experience in VC roles which they aren’t being referred for.

“Research shows that women are not being referred to for board roles due to the lack of Women in VC (venture capital) and investment roles. This is something the VC’s are working hard to change and it highlights how vital this is to facilitate a thriving and diverse ecosystem.”

If this trend continues and start-ups fail to address this underrepresentation of women adequately, the tech industry runs the risk of “insularity” says Price.

“Diversity extends beyond skills and experience,” she says. “As globalisation and the shifting demographics of markets and the workforce make startups more dependent on diversity, a board built on homogeneous relationships has the inherent risk of insularity.”

“What we need to do to support Australian startups is to re-write the playbook – by providing a guide and insight into what best practice should look like. As well as identifying ways to increase diversity, and set benchmarks for governance that enable founders to perform at their best.”

Stay Smart! Get Savvy!

Get Women's Agenda in your inbox