The polls were wrong in the last US and Australian federal elections. Hillary Clinton was favoured to win at a margin of 85% to Donald Trump’s 15%. And Bill Shorten was expected to defeat Scott Morrison.
But what the polls perhaps didn’t reveal was that conservative candidates in both countries had captured an unexpected electorate: women.
Bill Shorten also lost women’s votes, pushing them towards the Coalition.
Women are swinging elections in the US and Australia in ways analysts have struggled to predict. So, what is going on with female voters? Our two recent studies can help explain.
Gender linked fate
Our earlier study suggests a key to understanding women’s political attitudes is their perception their futures are connected to what happens to other women, or their “gender linked fate”.
The idea of a linked fate has long been used to explain voting patterns of racial minority groups. Individual African-Americans, for example, have generally understood their futures to be closely tied to the well-being of the whole group.
This sense of linked fate helps explain why African-Americans vote as a block for more liberal candidates. Supporting the group is more important than individual preferences.
In this study, we assessed whether women experience a sense of linked fate to other women. And we found something striking in our US sample. Women’s perceptions of gender linked fate were contingent on two dimensions: their race and their marital status.
African-American women reported higher levels of gender-linked fate than whites, regardless of whether they were married, single or divorced. But for white and Latina women, gender-linked fate was tied to their marital status.
Only 18% of married white women reported their futures were strongly connected to other women compared to 38% of single and 30% of divorced white women. The patterns are similar for Latina women. This means for these two racial groups, heterosexual marriage leads them to feel less connected to other women.
Marriage is shown to shift couples’ attitudes, making them more similar to each other over the course of marriage. But, the shift is not even.
Rather, women become more conservative and see themselves as less connected to other women over the duration of the marriage.
Single women, on the other hand, are more supportive of feminist issues than married women, with feminist attitudes intensifying for women who rely more heavily on their own earnings.
Essentially, the institution of marriage traditionalises women’s attitudes and, as our study shows, this is pronounced for white women.
Weak gender linked fate
In the US, we found white married women’s lower levels of gender-linked fate helps explain their tendency to identify as a conservative and vote for the Republican party, and their weaker support for abortion.
These findings are important in the context of American politics. The election of Donald Trump and the passage of heartbeat bills (a ban of any abortion once a heartbeat of a fetus can be detected, six to eight weeks after conception) across six US states are major swings to the right.
The assumption that women would vote for Clinton or that women would support abortion because they are women are not shown in the data.
Our research helps explain one piece of this puzzle – married white and Latina women don’t necessarily see their futures as tied to other women.
So, who are they tied to? Our research suggests men.
Women’s connection to men
We have since collected new data on 317 American white women and asked them about their connection to women and men.
From our interviews, we found conservative women were more likely to report that as things get better for men, they believed their own life also improved. Women who are more liberal were less likely to agree with this statement.
In contrast, liberal married women were more likely to say they would give up some of their resources (such as economic resources or class privilege) to benefit other women – a claim conservative women by and large did not make.
And, more politically liberal women reported their connection to other women has strengthened by 25% in the current political climate, over the past two years, compared to 8% among conservative women.
Simply, conservative white women are less connected to other women and more connected to men.
The US is distinct in its racial, political and marital composition, but there are some lessons to be learned for the current Australian political climate.
The 2019 federal election showed women weren’t aligned with Labor in the way the polls predicted.
Something in Coalition’s message resonates with Australian women. Our research suggests these messages may be particularly powerful to certain groups of women – married, white and conservative – who are watching their family’s futures change.
Leah Ruppanner, Associate Professor in Sociology and Co-Director of The Policy Lab, University of Melbourne; Christopher Stout, Assistant Professor of Political Science, Oregon State University; Gosia Mikolajczak, Research fellow, University of Melbourne, and Kelsy Kretschmer, Assistant Professor of Sociology, Oregon State University